Navigation
Thursday
May032018

Recurring spectrum fees

This paper considers the impact of recurring spectrum fees. It concludes that fees in relation to mobile use do not promote the optimal use of spectrum since operators face their own use opportunity cost, irrespective of fees, in terms of the trade-off between meeting data demand growth through more intensive use of existing spectrum (including investing in mobile sites) and the purchase of additional spectrum in future. Further, given the ongoing reallocation of spectrum for mobile use, mobile use has higher value than alternative use at the margin. Mobile operators therefore face the opportunity cost of spectrum absent fees, whilst fees may harm investment. 

Wednesday
Jun072017

Regulatory Independence - Revisited

In this note, Brian Williamson revists the rationale for regulatory independence, and how it fits with increasing government ambitions for network infrastructure

Friday
May202016

Regulatory Trade-offs

Communications policy and regulatory objectives are wide ranging and complex. Countries seek affordable, diverse, widely available and used services of a high quality, but virtually all regulatory decisions involve trade-offs between these objectives. A given decision may support one policy objective, but perhaps impede another, or come at a cash cost to be borne by the treasury.

Communications Chambers worked with the WEF and Vodafone to understand such trade-offs, and to develop an online 'spirit level' tool to map of how countries around the world are striking different balances between telecoms objectives.

The tool and the associated paper are available here

Monday
Oct072024

Response to CMA Issues Statement re Vodafone-Three Merger

In this paper, Stephen Howard discusses the CMA’s Provisional Findings and Possible Remedies regarding the proposed Vodafone-Three UK merger, explaining why it merits approval without remedies that would prove counter-productive

Tuesday
Sep012026

Reviewing DCMS' DTT CBA

In this paper for ETV, Robert Kenny critiques DCMS' preliminary CBA for the transition from DTT to IPTV in either 2034 or 2044.

DCMS emphasise that their CBA is preliminary. Bringing its approach into line with Treasury Green Book standards will show both a much higher benefit from the early release of spectrum enabled by a 2034 transition, and a lower assessed cost for broadband for households not online.

In combination with the various unquantified factors (which heavily favour an earlier transition), this suggests the final CBA will show an appreciable advantage for a 2034 transition.